Intelligent, handsome, and athletic, Buddy Willard is described as the perfect man in Sylvia Plath’s The Bell Jar. At first, Esther believes this herself. She “adored him from a distance for five years before he even looked at me”, but eventually “he was looking at me more and more I discovered quote by accident what an awful hypocrite he was” (52). It is through Buddy that Esther is first presented with the conventional idea that a woman’s role is society is to help the man, and not herself. This idea makes her confused, troubled, and isolated, as she feels that she is the only one who sees through these gender stereotypes.
Esther, or in fact any well-educated middle class girl at the time, is expected to do nothing more in life than find a husband. She hears this when Mrs. Willard explains to Buddy “What a man is is an arrow into the future, and what a woman is is the place the arrow shoots off from”. This quote reminded me exactly of the quote “behind every successful man there is a woman”, which implies that a woman’s role is to support her husband and nurture him so he can fulfill his ambitions. A woman should, according to these quotes, strive to help their husband rather than work towards their own goals. This societal norm disturbs Esther, who has worked her whole life for herself. She has achieved such a status and intelligence that to throw it all away for a man doesn’t make any sense to her. She realizes that she cannot work towards a marriage and career because marrying someone would mean she would have to let go of her writing career.
It's really interesting to see how Esther thinks and acts this way despite that time period and its usual expectations from a woman. Even though Esther isn't real, I'm really glad that she didn't end up with Buddy and have to give up what she wants to do. Maybe even old Holden would be proud of her!
ReplyDeleteEsther was really brave for seeing the sexual double standard and actually doing something about it because nobody else around her encouraged her to do that. When she talked to her friends, they all said it was normal for boys to act like that but Esther didn't think it was right and reacted.
ReplyDeleteI agree with your general sentiments about society's ideas about what a woman's role is, but I'm not sure that I agree with your interpretation of the saying. I think that the saying "behind every successful man there is a woman" is actually meant to highlight the importance of women, and not necessarily saying that women are always behind men. It isn't perfect but I don't think that its meaning undermines women. Of course there are other issues with the saying, but I think that it is generally emphasizing the importance of mothers, wives, etc. in a society where men were often thought to be be the bread-winners/ innovation drivers.
ReplyDeleteThis reminds me of when Esther first meets with Dr. Gordon. I love the detail when she's looking at Dr. Gordon's wife in the picture, how she's beautiful and the family is circling around Gordon "like a halo." While I might be reading into it too much, I thought that line suggested the sort of dependence of women on their men, like she's a product of his success just like their children, and her goal is to be a trophy of his, like a halo. I also really agree with your point about the sayings!
ReplyDeleteI think that Buddy Williard is very expectant of Esther to marry her, and in this sense goes against the independence and hard work that Esther herself believes in. I think that Buddy is pretty representative of the illusion and confinement of life as characterized by the Bell Jar in that he seems to set boundaries and lies surrounding Esther just so Esther will simply devote her life to him.
ReplyDeleteI think it's interesting how Esther tries to go against the sexual double standard not just by complaining about it, but by raising herself to Buddy's level. Her solution is not to demand that Buddy remain "pure", but to decide to have her own sexual experience so that he will have to relate to her as an equal.
ReplyDeleteA big part of Esther's deep (and sudden) sense of disillusionment has to do with the impression that she's been duped in some way: all these years in school, she's been rewarded for her strong efforts, and encouraged to continue in her academic pursuits, and now that she's poised to graduate, she gets the message that all that poetry and literature stuff doesn't really matter, it's really all about whom she marries (as Buddy promises she'll forget all about poetry after having a couple of kids). The role is confining, from her point of view (and it seems like she's been sure she'll "never get married" for a long time now), but even worse is this sense that her schools have given her a false impression, tricked her into playing this game only to position her to take shorthand and find a good husband.
ReplyDeleteA lot of blog posts have been written about Buddy, so I think everyone obviously pinpoints him as one of the sources of Esther's "derailment". I agree that your quote about the arrow is really similar to the saying about men being successful. Often this quote is used to show that women are important even though it's actually quite a problematic saying. I think that this can be tied to Esther's frustration with society in general: people think that the role women are playing is fine, but Esther feels like it is not.
ReplyDelete